The fate of a mansion and former daycare centre in Penarth that’s been lying empty for years is to be decided.
Gardenhurst, which sits on the corner of Holmsdale Place and Marine Parade, was describe as being a “fine property” in its day by one local councillor.
The mansion was owned by the Pegler family before its life as a care facility and there have been a number of plans to bring it back to life as flats since it closed in 2014.
Cllr Anthony Earnest, who represents the Plymouth ward on Vale of Glamorgan Council, said it would be “one heck of a shame” if it was not brought back into use.
Plans to change the use of the building to provide six new flats and three new houses were submitted in 2016.
However, the application made to Vale Council has been subject to several changes over the years and a decision on whether or not it can go ahead has been pending ever since.
One planner at the council told us that an extension until 29th March 2025 to determine its future has been agreed.
The council planner said: “Should a further extension of time be required, a further agreement would be secured between the council and the agent prior to this date."
“Furthermore, the application has been called into planning committee by a local member, and as such, final determination will be made by members of planning committee.”
Another planning application to turn Gardenhurst into flats, made in 2015, was withdrawn.
If the current plans are given the go ahead, the three proposed terrace houses would be built on the existing car park of the property.
The once “fine” property is currently boarded up and would be easy to miss if you were walking past it, with it being surrounded by trees and shrubs.
Cllr Ernest said: “I would very much like to see this outstanding property in the Penarth Conservation Area brought back into more beneficial use so that it can continue to be a prominent building in the Penarth Conservation Area.”
Vale Council said discussions are ongoing in respect of the viability of the proposed scheme. The next council planning committee meeting is scheduled to take place on Thursday 27th March.

Another derelict building nearby on Bridgeman Road is also still waiting to be given a new lease of life.
Normandy House was called a “blot on the landscape” and a “complete mess” by local councillors.
The building’s roof has collapsed and one building expert said it would need to be partially demolished.
After conducting an assessment of Normandy House, R V Williams Associates said they had concerns about the stability of the chimney stacks and stated in a report that parts of the building, specifically parts of some windows, could “collapse at any time”.
Plans to restore the building as apartments were approved by the council in June 2022.

New details have emerged of a new tree-lined public square that will replace a traffic dominated junction. v.1
Dyffryn Gardens’ Edwardian rose garden blooms again after decade-long restoration
Barry’s Own Daniel White to Walk 190 Miles Back to Where His Round Table Story Began
1,300 people attend Flying Start Family Fun Day
Dispersal order put in place to tackle anti-social behaviour
Interim Chief Executive Appointed at Cardiff and Vale University Health Board
Cardiff Theatre Marks 50 Years of Service for Long‑Standing Staff Member
Council to review use of GP letters as evidence for disability claims
Plans have been put in place to redevelop a complex with more than 20 flats
Vale Council Reaccredited Under White Ribbon Scheme as Part of Ongoing Work to Tackle Violence Against Women and Girls
Two Vale Restaurants Among Those Set to Close as Whitbread Shuts Brewers Fayre and Beefeater Chains
Vale Council Issues Safety Warning After Gas Canisters Found in Household Recycling
Cogan Primary School Praised for its Inclusive Culture and Strong Leadership in Estyn Inspection
Senedd Members Call to Tackle Substance Use Stigma
Calls for Welsh Government to Match England's Pub Business Rates Cut
Caerdydd Penarth MS backs campaign to make rail station more accessible
Barry Waterfront Regeneration Project Moves a Step Closer
Age Cymru Responds to VAT cut to household electricity bills
Old Post Office in St Brides Major could be converted into a new house and set of flats